Ronald Hutton

Ronald Hutton FBA
Born	Ronald Edmund Hutton (1953-12-19) 19 December 1953 Ootacamund, India
Occupation	Historian, author
Known for	The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles (1991), The Rise and Fall of Merry England (1994), The Stations of the Sun (1996), The Triumph of the Moon (1999), Shamans (2001)
Title	Professor of History
Academic background
Alma mater	Pembroke College, Cambridge (BA) Magdalen College, Oxford (DPhil)
Thesis title	The Royalist war effort in Wales and the West Midlands, 1642-1646
Thesis url	https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:ada4858c-75a0-4749-be17-769b7ae97eb0
Thesis year	1980
Academic work
Discipline	History
Sub discipline	English folklore, pre-Christian religion, contemporary Paganism
Institutions	University of Bristol

Ronald Edmund Hutton FBA (born 19 December 1953) is an English historian who specialises in Early Modern Britain, British folklore, pre-Christian religion and Contemporary Paganism. He is a professor at the University of Bristol, has written 14 books and has appeared on British television and radio. He held a fellowship at Magdalen College, Oxford, and is a Commissioner of English Heritage.

Born in Ootacamund, India, his family returned to England, and he attended a school in Ilford and became particularly interested in archaeology. He volunteered in a number of excavations until 1976 and visited the country's chambered tombs. He studied history at Pembroke College, Cambridge, and then Magdalen College, Oxford, before he lectured in history at the University of Bristol from 1981. Specialising in Early Modern Britain, he wrote three books on the subject: The Royalist War Effort (1981), The Restoration (1985) and Charles the Second (1990).

In the 1990s, he wrote books about historical paganism, folklore and Contemporary Paganism in Britain; The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles (1991), The Rise and Fall of Merry England (1994), The Stations of the Sun (1996) and The Triumph of the Moon (1999), the latter of which would come to be praised as a seminal text in the discipline of Pagan studies. In the following decade, he wrote on other topics: a book about Siberian shamanism in the western imagination, Shamans (2001), a collection of essays on folklore and Paganism, Witches, Druids and King Arthur (2003) and then two books on the role of the Druids in the British imagination, The Druids (2007) and Blood and Mistletoe (2009).

He was elected a Fellow of the British Academy in 2013.

Biography

Early life: 1953–1980

"I had begun in the 1960s by believing completely in the concept of early modern witchcraft as a Pagan religion of feminism, liberation, and affirmation of life. In 1973 I debated against the historian Norman Cohn at Cambridge University, defending the historical legitimacy of Charles Godfrey Leland's "witches' gospel" Aradia, and was floored by him. During the rest of the decade my belief in the old orthodoxy concerning the witch trials slipped away, as I read more and more of the new research and checked the original records (for England and Scotland) myself."

Hutton on his views of European witchcraft, 2010.

Hutton was born on 19 December 1953 in Ootacamund, India to a colonial family, and is of part-Russian ancestry. Upon arriving in England, he attended Ilford County High School, whilst becoming greatly interested in archaeology, joining the committee of a local archaeological group and taking part in excavations from 1965 to 1976, including at such sites as Pilsdon Pen hill fort, Ascott-under-Wychwood long barrow, Hen Domen castle and a temple on Malta. Meanwhile, during the period between 1966 and 1969, he visited "every prehistoric chambered tomb surviving in England and Wales, and wrote a guide to them, for myself [Hutton] and friends."

Despite his love of archaeology, he instead decided to study history at university, believing that he had "probably more aptitude" for it. He won a scholarship to study at Pembroke College, Cambridge, where he continued his interest in archaeology alongside history, in 1975 taking a course run by the university's archaeologist Glyn Daniel, an expert on the Neolithic. From Cambridge, he went on to study at Oxford University, where he gained a Doctorate and took up a fellowship at Magdalen College.

Bristol University and first publications: 1981–1990

In 1981, Hutton moved to the University of Bristol where he took up the position of reader of History. In that year he also published his first book, 'The Royalist War Effort 1642–1646', and followed it with three more books on 17th century British history by 1990.

The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles: 1991–1993

Main article: The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles

Hutton followed his studies on the Early Modern period with a book on a very different subject, The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles: Their Nature and Legacy (1991), in which he attempted to "set out what is at present known about the religious beliefs and practices of the British Isles before their conversion to Christianity. The term 'pagan' is used as a convenient shorthand for those beliefs and practices, and is employed in the title merely to absolve the book from any need to discuss early Christianity itself." It thereby examined religion during the Palaeolithic, Neolithic, Bronze Age, Iron Age, Roman occupation and Anglo-Saxon period, as well as a brief examination of their influence on folklore and contemporary Paganism. In keeping with what was by then the prevailing academic view, it disputed the widely held idea that ancient paganism had survived into the contemporary and had been revived by the Pagan movement.

The book proved controversial amongst some contemporary Pagans and feminists involved in the Goddess movement, one of whom, Asphodel Long, issued a public criticism of Hutton in which she charged him with failing to take non-mainstream ideas about ancient goddess cults into consideration. Ultimately, Hutton would later relate, she "recognised that she had misunderstood me" and the two became friends. Another feminist critic, Max Dashu, condemned the work as containing "factual errors, mischaracterizations, and outright whoppers" and claimed that she was "staggered by the intense anti-feminism of this book". She went on to attack Hutton's writing style, calling the book "dry as dust" and claimed that she was "sorry I bothered to plough through it. If this is rigor, it is mortis."

Meanwhile, whilst he faced criticism from some sectors of the Pagan community in Britain, others came to embrace him; during the late 1980s and 1990s, Hutton befriended a number of practising British Pagans, including "leading Druids" such as Tim Sebastion, who was then Chief of the Secular Order of Druids. On the basis of The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles (which he himself had not actually read), Sebastion invited Hutton to speak at a conference in Avebury where he befriended a number of members of the Pagan Druidic movement, including Philip Carr-Gomm, Emma Restall Orr and John Michell.

Studies of British folklore: 1994–1996

In the following years, Hutton released two books on British folklore, both of which were published by Oxford University Press: The Rise and Fall of Merry England: The Ritual Year 1400–1700 (1994) and The Stations of the Sun: A History of the Ritual Year in Britain (1996). In these works he criticised commonly held attitudes, such as the idea of Merry England and the idea that folk customs were static and unchanging over the centuries. Once again, he was following prevailing expert opinion in doing so.

The Triumph of the Moon: 1997–1999

Main article: The Triumph of the Moon

In 1999, his first work fully focusing on Paganism was published by Oxford University Press; The Triumph of the Moon: A History of Modern Pagan Witchcraft. The book dealt with the history of the Pagan religion of Wicca, and in the preface Hutton stated that:

the subtitle of this book should really be 'a history of modern pagan witchcraft in South Britain (England, Wales, Cornwall and Man), with some reference to it in the rest of the British Isles, Continental Europe and North America'. The fact that it claims to be a history and not the history is in itself significant, for this book represents the first systematic attempt by a professional historian to characterise and account for this aspect of modern Western culture."

Hutton questioned many assumptions about Wicca's development and argued that many of the claimed connections to longstanding hidden pagan traditions are questionable at best. However, he also argued for its importance as a genuine new religious movement.

Response from the Neopagan community

The response from the Neopagan community was somewhat mixed. Many Pagans embraced his work, with the prominent Wiccan Elder Frederic Lamond referring to it as "an authority on the history of Gardnerian Wicca". Public criticism came from the practising Wiccan Jani Farrell-Roberts, who took part in a published debate with Hutton in The Cauldron magazine in 2003. Farrell-Roberts was of the opinion that in his works, Hutton dismissed Margaret Murray's theories about the Witch-Cult using Norman Cohn's theories, which she believed to be heavily flawed. She stated that "he is... wrongly cited as an objective neutral and a 'non-pagan' for he happens to be a very active member of the British Pagan community" who "had taken on a mission to reform modern paganism by removing from it a false history and sense of continuance".

Shamans and Witches, Druids and King Arthur: 2000–2006

Hutton next turned his attention to Siberian shamanism, with Hambledon and London publishing Shamans: Siberian Spirituality in the Western Imagination in 2001, in which he argued that much of what westerners think they know about shamanism is in fact wrong.

In his review for the academic Folklore journal, Jonathan Roper of the University of Sheffield noted that the work "could profitably have been twice as long and have provided a more extended treatment of the issues involved" and that it suffered from a lack of images. On the whole however he thought it "certainly [should] be recommended to readers as an important work" on the subject of shamanism, and he hoped that Hutton would "return to treat this fascinating topic in even greater depth in future."

In 2003, Hambledon & London also published Witches, Druids and King Arthur, a collection of various articles by Hutton, including on topics such as the nature of myth and the pagan themes found within the works of J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis.

The Druids and Blood and Mistletoe: 2007–2009

"Predictably, Hutton finds himself defending his position on two fronts. Neo-pagans, clinging to the notion that their beliefs are part of an ancient nature religion, and radical feminists upholding the idea of a primeval matriarchal society (which Hutton finds "rather delightful"), scorn Hutton's refreshingly cheerful acceptance that there seems little evidence for either of these. And his less unbuttoned colleagues shake their heads at his optimism about Druidry and other 'alternative spiritualities' as valid contemporary religions."

Gary Lachman, 2007.

After studying the history of Wicca, Hutton went on to look at the history of Druidry, both the historical and the contemporary. His first book on the subject, The Druids, was published in 2007. Part of this material was given as the first lecture of the Mount Haemus Award series. Hutton's next book, which was also about Druidry, was entitled Blood and Mistletoe: The History of the Druids in Britain, and released in May 2009.

In a review by David V. Barrett in The Independent, Blood and Mistletoe was described as being more "academic and more than three times the length" of The Druids, although Barrett argued that despite this it was still "very readable", even going so far as to call it a "tour de force". The review by Noel Malcolm in The Daily Telegraph was a little more critical, claiming that whilst Hutton was "non-sensationalist and scrupulously polite" about the various Druidic eccentrics, "occasionally, even-handedness tips over towards relativism – as if there are just different ways of looking at reality, each as good as the other. And that cannot be right."

Personal life

"My colleagues would kill me for saying this, but historians are increasingly conscious of the fact that we can't write history. What we can write about is the way in which people see history and think history happens."

Hutton on history, 2007.

Hutton was married to Lisa Radulovic from August 1988 to March 2003, when they divorced. Although he has written much on the subject of Paganism, Hutton insists that his own religious beliefs are a private matter. He has instead stated that "to some extent history occupies the space in my life filled in that of others by religion or spirituality. It defines much of the way I come to terms with the cosmos, and with past, present and future." He was raised Pagan, and was personally acquainted with Wiccans from youth. He has become a "well-known and much loved figure" in the British Pagan community.

Interviewing Hutton for The Independent, the journalist Gary Lachman commented that he had "a very pragmatic, creative attitude, recognising that factual error can still produce beneficial results", for instance noting that even though their theories about the Early Modern Witch-Cult were erroneous, Margaret Murray and Gerald Gardner would help lay the foundations for the creation of the new religious movement of Wicca.

Works

Hutton's books can be divided into those about seventeenth-century Britain and those about paganism and folk customs in Britain.

Seventeenth century Britain

In his What If the Gunpowder Plot Had Succeeded?, Hutton has considered what might have happened if the Gunpowder Plot of 1605 had succeeded in its aims of the death of King James I and the destruction of the House of Lords. He concluded that the violence of the act would have resulted in an even more severe backlash against suspected Catholics than was caused by its failure, as most Englishmen were loyal to the monarchy, despite differing religious convictions. England could very well have become a more "Puritan absolute monarchy", rather than following the path of parliamentary and civil reform.

Bibliography

Books

Title	Year	Publisher	ISBN
The Royalist War Effort 1642–1646	1982	Routledge (London)
The Restoration: A Political and Religious History of England and Wales 1658–1660	1985	Clarendon	0-19-822698-5
Charles the Second, King of England, Scotland and Ireland	1989	Clarendon	0-19-822911-9
The British Republic 1649–1660	1990	Palgrave Macmillan
The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles: Their Nature and Legacy	1991	Blackwell (Oxford and Cambridge)	0-631-18946-7
The Rise and Fall of Merry England: The Ritual Year 1400–1700	1994	Oxford University Press (Oxford and New York)	9 780198-203636
The Stations of the Sun: A History of the Ritual Year in Britain	1996	Oxford University Press (Oxford and New York)
The Triumph of the Moon: A History of Modern Pagan Witchcraft	1999	Oxford University Press (Oxford and New York)	9 780198 207443
Shamans: Siberian Spirituality and the Western Imagination	2001	Hambledon and London (London and New York)	1-85295-324-7
Witches, Druids and King Arthur	2003	Hambledon
Debates in Stuart History	2004	Palgrave Macmillan
The Druids: A History	2007	Hambledon Continuum
Blood and Mistletoe: The History of the Druids in Britain	2009	Yale University Press (London)	978-0-300-14485-7
A Brief History of Britain 1485–1660: The Tudor and Stuart Dynasties	2011	Robinson	978-1845297046
Pagan Britain	2013	Oxford University Press	978-0300197716
The Witch: A History of Fear, from Ancient Times to the Present	2017	Yale University Press	978-0300229042
The Making of Oliver Cromwell	2021	Yale University Press	978-0300257458
Queens of the Wild: Pagan Goddesses in Christian Europe: An Investigation	2022	Yale University Press	978-0300261011

Journal articles

• "Romano-British Reuse of Prehistoric Ritual Sites" in Britannia Vol. 42 (2011), pp. 1–22.

Tapes

• England's Haunted Hills the Cotswolds

1991 Educational Excursions 1-878877-06-2

Documentaries

• Britain's Wicca Man, documentary on Wicca and Gerald Gardener, 2012.
• A Very British Witchcraft, documentary, 2013.
• Professor Hutton's Curiosities, documentary series, 2013.

Appearances

• Scariest Places on Earth
• Unsolved Mysteries (Episode #10.3, 1998)
• Tales from the Green Valley
• Edwardian Farm
• Victorian Farm, documentary series following three historians as they live the life of Victorian farmers.
• Tudor Monastery Farm
• The Pagans
• Ancient Aliens
• Secrets of Great British Castles
• The Pendle Witch Child

Reviews and assessment

Academic reviews

• Donald Frew. Methodological Flaws in Recent Studies of Historical & Modern Witchcraft. Ethnologies, Vol. 20 #1, (1998): pp. 33-65.
• Barry Collett, Review of Stations of the Sun, Sixteenth Century Journal, 29/1 (1998): 241–243.
• Christopher W. Marsh, Review of Stations of the Sun, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, 50 (1999): 133–135.
• Jonathan Roper, Review of Shamans, Folklore, April 2005,
• Chas S. Clifton, Review of Witches, Druids and King Arthur Archived 1 October 2011 at the Wayback Machine, The Pomegranate: The International Journal of Pagan Studies, 7/1 (2005): 101–103.
• Christopher Chippindale, Review of The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles, History Today, (1992)
• de Blécourt, Dr Willem (2017). Review of The Witch, Reviews in History
• Hill, Dr. J. D. (2004) A Reply to Ronald Hutton’s Commentary 'What did Happen to Lindow Man?’ TLS 30 Jan at the Wayback Machine (archived 8 January 2006). Sent to The Times Literary Supplement 7 February 2004. (Hutton's original article available here at the Wayback Machine (archived 28 August 2005)) (A critical review)

Other reviews

• Whitmore, Ben. Trials of the Moon: Reopening the Case for Historical Witchcraft, 2010.
• Margaret Murray and the Distinguished Professor Hutton at the Wayback Machine (archived 20 April 2008) by Jani Farrell-Roberts: originally published as The Great Debate by Farrell-Roberts and Hutton in The Cauldron, 2003.
• Long, Asphodel P. (1992) Review of "The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles", Wood and Water 39, Summer 1992.
• Barrett, David V., 21 July 2007, Independent. Book review: The Druids: A History
• Hutton, Ronald, 01/12/1996, history.ac.uk, Review of The Witch in History: Early Modern and Twentieth-Century Representations.
• A review of Ronald Hutton's The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles by Max Dashu, 1998 (suppressedhistories.net).
• A Review of Ronald Hutton's Blood and Mistletoe in the Independent
• The Roots of Witchcraft: A study of the effects of hallucinogenic plants can explain much about sorcery and demonic possession through the ages by Robert Carver in The Spectator (a review of The Witch by Ronald Hutton)]

References

Footnotes

Sources

Academic books

Non-academic sources

External links

• University of Bristol: Department of History: Prof. Ronald Hutton
• Ronald Hutton at the Internet Movie Database
• The Origins of Modern Druidry by Ronald Hutton, Mt Haemus Award Lecture
• An Interview with Ronald Hutton in which he talks about his historical work and spiritual path
• Listen to 'The Changing Face of Manx Witchcraft'. A Public lecture by Professor Ronald Hutton at the Manx Museum, 15 January 2010